Go to content
VM - Logo
VM - Logo
Vigilant Minds Header
Skip menu
Vigilant Minds - Page Menu
Skip menu
The True Story Behind ‘Under the Banner of Heaven’
Vigilant Minds
Published by Don McAreavy in Mormonism · Friday 24 Oct 2025 · Read time 3:00
Tags: MormonNews

Source: NewsBreak - AXIOS

It’s pretty horrible, fair warning!

By Courtney Young -

FX’s long-awaited true-crime drama, Under the Banner of Heaven, is finally here! Starring Oscar-nominated theater kid Andrew Garfield and directed by Hell or High Water’s David Mackenzie, Under the Banner of Heaven follows a police detective whose faith in humanity is tested as he investigates a double murder involving the Mormon church.

With Andrew behind the badge, the series also stars Normal People and Fresh star Daisy Edgar-Jones and Avatar’s leading man, Sam Worthington. With a grim true story, a hugely talented cast, and a bit of religious extremism, Under the Banner of Heaven is one of the most anticipated TV shows of the year.

The original source material—a Jon Krakauer nonfiction book titled Under the Banner of Heaven: A Story of Violent Faith—was  published in 2003. The book weaves together two stories: the origin of  the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints (aka the Mormon church)  and a vicious double murder committed by fundamentalist brothers in  1984.

Vigilant Minds has a few copies of "Under The Banner of Heaven" for free if anyone is interested (Contact Us) If You would like a free copy..  Jon Krakauer is a celebrated best selling author and is not a Christian.  His research is impeccable and his capturing of the brutal events involving "Blood Atonement" are historically accurate.  The series, out on Hulu, is well worth the watch.


The murder made headlines when Ron and Dan Lafferty were convicted of killing their sister-in-law Brenda Lafferty and her 15-month-old daughter, Erica, in July 1984. As for the motive, Ron claimed to have received a divine revelation from God instructing him to remove people from the Earth.

The Lafferty brothers were members of a small group called the School of Prophets.  As the story goes, Ron’s extreme religious views led to him being  excommunicated from the LDS church. Not long after, his wife left him  and took their six children to Florida. The brothers were said to have blamed Brenda, who was married to their youngest brother, Allen, and had been critical of the brothers’ extreme fundamentalist views.

After  being ousted from the LDS church, the brothers leaned into the School  of Prophets. Ron claimed to receive messages from God about Brenda and  shared his “removal revelation” with the other members, who quickly  rebuffed the idea of murdering a woman and her infant child. Not long  after, the brothers quit the School of Prophets…and then Brenda and her  baby were found dead.

Ultimately, the brothers were caught when the police found a written note detailing the plan, and Utah v. Lafferty was officially underway.

Former American Fork Police Department Chief Terry Fox was a detective at the time, and he told Salt Lake City’s KSLTV in 2019 that even though he’d “seen a lot of death” in his career, “this one was different, in the case that it was religiously motivated. You can use the word ‘brutal,’ ‘horrific.’ And I just don’t throw those out lightly, because this was a really, really brutal murder. It was different from a lot of crime scenes in a lot of ways.”....




© Copyright 2026 - Vigilant Minds
Created with Website X5
© Copyright 2026 - Vigilant Minds
Back to content